The Making of the World's First Web Band, the ClipBandits
From web cams to performing on Tyra Banks Show in 30 days! Play these videos to see...

ClipBandits on: Good Morning America and ABC World News

    

Discuss American Idol:

3636 messages  

Message Sent Thursday, May 19, 2011 3:31 pm (Pacific Time)
From: East Alton, IL, US
Area Code: 618
Zip Code: 62024          
Add a message

They quit when Adam didn't win. He should have, and I think this poll was very accurate with Adam in 1st, but maybe the producers didn't think he should win.

Message Sent Tuesday, May 17, 2011 10:15 am (Pacific Time)
From: , ,
Area Code: Unknown
Zip Code: Unknown          
Add a message

Why after the use of your site am I not allowed to do any more searches,It says I have used all searches available. Call me and let me know why,at

Message Sent Friday, May 13, 2011 6:34 am (Pacific Time)
From: Cleveland, OH, US
Area Code: 216
Zip Code: 44114          
Add a message

All the comments are absolutely right. I live in Canada, and did not vote, but I was unaware that there was a voting problem. I certainly hope that this will be looked into, and corrected.

Message Sent Friday, May 13, 2011 6:28 am (Pacific Time)
From: Stony Ridge, OH, US
Area Code: 419
Zip Code: 43463          
Add a message

i believe that AI is going to lose a ton of viewers after last night's results. we saw this last year with Adam and have seen it many times before. i never miss the show, but i will not watch it again after this year. it is too disappointing. something has to be done about the way the voting is done. it is like having a union shop, and you have to get rid of the good guy because of seniority. you guys are getting rid of the good guys because they dont have as many friends.

Message Sent Friday, May 13, 2011 12:41 am (Pacific Time)
From: Cleburne, TX, US
Area Code: 817
Zip Code: 76033          
Add a message

I am so angry about the elimination of James Durbin. It is just wrong how the new voting system works. Preteens stay up voting all night online for the teenagers on the show. The voting should be limited to ten votes per e-mail address and 5 votes per phone and text. 72 million votes - a joke. People could not get through on the phone to vote for James and the online voting didn't close until 4.00 in the morning. AI NEEDS TO FIX THIS PROBLEM!!!! Won't watch the rest of the season.

Message Sent Thursday, May 12, 2011 8:07 pm (Pacific Time)
From: Boise, ID, US
Area Code: 208
Zip Code: Unknown          
Add a message

I really think the voting system is broken. James was the far best performer in idol recent history. James should of won the whole thing. I cant believe that Haley even made it, she is not good. Me and alot of others are done watching.

Message Sent Thursday, May 12, 2011 7:27 pm (Pacific Time)
From: , ,
Area Code: Unknown
Zip Code: Unknown          
Add a message

you need to check the results again because people had trouble geeting through on line 1 for james we got a recording that said not a working line let's be fair check the voting system it was not right on voting wenesday night May 11 2011 James got cheating you have lost a lot of viewers

Message Sent Thursday, May 5, 2011 10:39 pm (Pacific Time)
From: Lehi, UT, US
Area Code: 801
Zip Code: 84043          
Add a message

Just wanted to say thank you to Jennifer Lopez for not showing too much skin as an American Idol judge (for the most part), so that I feel comfortable letting my younger children watch the show.

Message Sent Monday, May 2, 2011 3:30 pm (Pacific Time)
From: San Francisco, CA, US
Area Code: 415
Zip Code: 94104          
Add a message

I'd like to opt out from your web-site. I've located my name & personal information and would like to know where to fax REMOVE to, thank you! Louise Heilman 650 274 3322

Message Sent Thursday, April 21, 2011 5:59 am (Pacific Time)
From: Kissimmee, FL, US
Area Code: 407
Zip Code: Unknown          
Add a message

Last night the song that Scotty did was from John Anderson not Leann Rimes.

Message Sent Wednesday, April 20, 2011 6:04 pm (Pacific Time)
From: , , US
Area Code: Unknown
Zip Code: Unknown          
Add a message

Although this week featured songs from the 21st century, I was upset that the song "Swingin" (sung by Scotty) was credited to Leann Rimes. with no mention given to the original artist and songwriter, John Anderson. I am a citizen of Apopka, FL and since he grew up here, John Anderson is one of our hometown heroes. I would have liked to hear him given some credit for the song, especially since the version that Scotty sang was closer to the 1982 original than Leann's more recent reincarnation.

Message Sent Wednesday, April 13, 2011 6:29 pm (Pacific Time)
From: Clemmons, NC, US
Area Code: 336
Zip Code: 27012          
Add a message

You rock dude.

Message Sent Wednesday, April 13, 2011 6:26 pm (Pacific Time)
From: Clemmons, NC, US
Area Code: 336
Zip Code: 27012          
Add a message

You rock dog.

Message Sent Monday, April 11, 2011 7:46 am (Pacific Time)
From: San Diego, CA, US
Area Code: 619
Zip Code: Unknown          
Add a message

The elimination of Pia was indeed shocking HOWEVER, each one of those judges owe an apology to that young man, Stefano. The way they carried on and on about how wrong it was Pia was eliminated and all the while you could see how emotionally upset this young man was. After all, IT'S NOT HIS FAULT THAT THIS IS THE WAY AMERICA VOTED! Every one of those judges should be ashamed of their behavior!

Message Sent Sunday, April 10, 2011 1:16 pm (Pacific Time)
From: Matthews, NC, US
Area Code: 704
Zip Code: 28105          
Add a message

Why have you guys stopped this American Idol spoliers it was my most trusted source.

Message Sent Saturday, April 9, 2011 7:33 am (Pacific Time)
From: Pataskala, OH, US
Area Code: 740
Zip Code: 43062          
Add a message

I believe the judges owe the remaining 8 contestents a HUGE apology. Pia may have been talented; but so are the rest of them! Just because Pia was "their" favorite; she obviously wasn't Americas favorite and it was VERY disrespectful to let the other contestents know their disappoinment! They have all worked hard and one by one will be eliminated. But they each desearve respect. Especially from the people that represent American Idol. The right thing to do would be to offer a public apology.

Message Sent Friday, April 8, 2011 9:08 pm (Pacific Time)
From: , ,
Area Code: Unknown
Zip Code: Unknown          
Add a message

Used to watch american idol all the time. Since your show can't recognize talent ie Pia, I will no longer watch your show. Good luck with the lack of talent that's left and the downward spiral that your show is headed towards.

Message Sent Friday, April 8, 2011 3:16 pm (Pacific Time)
From: Denver, CO, US
Area Code: 303
Zip Code: Unknown          
Add a message

Bring Pia back! She is the most talented of the whole group. Change the rules

Message Sent Friday, April 8, 2011 2:32 pm (Pacific Time)
From: Mount Pleasant, SC, US
Area Code: 843
Zip Code: 29464          
Add a message

I knew when the judges wasted the save two weeks ago on Casey that it would come back to bite them. The save should be used for someone who can win American Idol, not someone you like. Casey can not win and now neither can Pia. I hope the judges realize the huge mistake they made.

Message Sent Friday, April 8, 2011 5:52 am (Pacific Time)
From: , ,
Area Code: Unknown
Zip Code: Unknown          
Add a message

After last nights debacle I think you should change the way contestants are eliminated. You could still have the fans vote for their favorite each show, but the judges the next day would pick the 3 contestants they think should be in the bottom 3, Then based on fan vote the contestant with the least votes of the three would be voted off. After it got to 3 then it would be just fan vote. It would avoid something like this happening again. My family and 5 children love the show. Will miss Pia.

Message Sent Thursday, April 7, 2011 6:58 pm (Pacific Time)
From: Knoxville, AR, US
Area Code: 479
Zip Code: 72845          
Add a message

I feel like the results of tonight's show need to be looked at and possibly even recounted. Something definitely went wrong.

Message Sent Thursday, April 7, 2011 6:54 pm (Pacific Time)
From: Knoxville, AR, US
Area Code: 479
Zip Code: 72845          
Add a message

It is total ridiculous that Pia is gone. Please find a way to bring her back. She is one of the best contestants on the show. There other people that should have went home before her. I am total aggravated and disappointed.

Message Sent Thursday, April 7, 2011 6:41 pm (Pacific Time)
From: Allston, MA, US
Area Code: 617
Zip Code: 02134          
Add a message

I have been watching tv for many years and never seen such an injustice as I saw tonight. Pia was definitely the best talent on the show. If she is not brought back, I will never watch another episode and I know many others will do the same. Do the unprecedended and bring her back. Your ratings will skyrocket. Perhaps it is time to re-visit the voting process. This result is unacceptable. Pia has the talent to become as popular as Kerry Underwood and she is now off the show. Ridiculous !!

Message Sent Thursday, April 7, 2011 11:29 am (Pacific Time)
From: Ardsley, NY, US
Area Code: 914
Zip Code: 10502          
Add a message

Glad to see this site gave up making predictions. Funny how that happened after they got caught changing their own incorrect predictions *after* they knew the results (proven). lol Hey, guess what? I can do that, too! Maybe I can get a site of my own? lol

Message Sent Sunday, March 27, 2011 11:04 am (Pacific Time)
From: Brentwood, TN, US
Area Code: 615
Zip Code: 37027          
Add a message

I have been a fan of the show for years but I think this year has the best crop of talent I have seen.I think there is a mix of every genre of music, which is why I think it would be interesting to see you guys have a Jazz night.I know that a lot of folks probably do not have a huge repertoire that they are familiar with but,I think considering the voices that are on the show that it would be a great challenge for them.(B.Holiday,L.Armstrong,Manhattan Transfer,C.Parker,M.Davis)What a Challenge

First Previous Next Last